The IRS does not consider ROBS an abusive tax avoidance transaction, but it calls the arrangements "questionable," and the problems it found trace back to how plans were set up and run. That puts the quality of your ROBS provider close to the center of your risk.
The IRS began its ROBS compliance project in 2009. It reported that many ROBS businesses failed or were failing, and that some owners lost both the business and their retirement savings.
- Many plan sponsors did not file Form 5500 or Form 1120, often after promoters wrongly told them the one-participant Form 5500-EZ exception applied. It does not, because the plan owns the business.
- Some plans were amended so later employees could not buy stock, which creates coverage and discrimination problems.
- Promoter fees, poor asset valuation, and missing Form 1099-R on the rollover also showed up.
The IRS's 2008 guidelines memo names two main concerns: discrimination in benefits, rights, and features, and prohibited transactions arising from deficient stock valuations, including thin one-page appraisals and promoter fees paid from plan assets. The prohibited-transaction excise tax is 15% of the amount involved, rising to 100% if it is not corrected.
One more point matters when you read provider marketing: a favorable determination letter is not IRS approval of how the plan is operated. Most of the failures above were operational, which is why the questions you ask a ROBS provider should be about filings, valuations, and plan access. Our ROBS compliance guide covers the ongoing obligations in more detail.