BlogROBS Providers
ROBS

How to Choose a ROBS Provider: 12 Questions to Ask

A plain-English vetting guide built on what the IRS found when it reviewed ROBS plans, with the questions to ask any provider before you move your retirement savings.

Al Lesko, founder of Fund My Franchise

Al Lesko

Fund My Franchise

8 min read

Franchise buyer at a kitchen table comparing two printed ROBS provider proposals side by side

Search for the best ROBS providers and nearly every result is written by a provider or an affiliate, and each one ranks itself first. This guide takes a different route. It explains what ROBS providers do, what the IRS found when it looked at these arrangements, and how to vet a ROBS provider before you move retirement savings into a franchise.

It is built around twelve questions you can put to any ROBS provider, including the one we work with. If you want the mechanics of the structure first, start with the ROBS 401(k) rules and come back.

What do ROBS providers actually do?

A ROBS provider designs and installs the plan, then administers it for as long as it exists. A ROBS provider is not your lawyer, your CPA, or your lender, and it does not decide whether Rollover as Business Start-ups (ROBS) suits your situation.

Typical work includes forming the C corporation, adopting a 401(k) plan, coordinating the rollover from your prior custodian, arranging the stock valuation, and handling annual filings such as Form 5500. For a step-by-step view of that sequence, see our 401(k) rollover service page.

What a provider does not do is guarantee that the business succeeds, or that you will never be examined. The structure puts retirement money into business equity, and that risk stays with you.

What did the IRS find when it reviewed ROBS plans?

The IRS does not consider ROBS an abusive tax avoidance transaction, but it calls the arrangements "questionable," and the problems it found trace back to how plans were set up and run. That puts the quality of your ROBS provider close to the center of your risk.

The IRS began its ROBS compliance project in 2009. It reported that many ROBS businesses failed or were failing, and that some owners lost both the business and their retirement savings.

  • Many plan sponsors did not file Form 5500 or Form 1120, often after promoters wrongly told them the one-participant Form 5500-EZ exception applied. It does not, because the plan owns the business.
  • Some plans were amended so later employees could not buy stock, which creates coverage and discrimination problems.
  • Promoter fees, poor asset valuation, and missing Form 1099-R on the rollover also showed up.

The IRS's 2008 guidelines memo names two main concerns: discrimination in benefits, rights, and features, and prohibited transactions arising from deficient stock valuations, including thin one-page appraisals and promoter fees paid from plan assets. The prohibited-transaction excise tax is 15% of the amount involved, rising to 100% if it is not corrected.

One more point matters when you read provider marketing: a favorable determination letter is not IRS approval of how the plan is operated. Most of the failures above were operational, which is why the questions you ask a ROBS provider should be about filings, valuations, and plan access. Our ROBS compliance guide covers the ongoing obligations in more detail.

What should a ROBS provider's fees cover?

Most ROBS providers charge a one-time setup fee, commonly around $3,500 to $5,500, plus ongoing plan administration of roughly $100 to $200 a month. Those two numbers are what you will hear quoted first, but they are rarely the whole bill.

Before you compare quotes, make sure each one accounts for the same pieces. A ROBS plan typically involves:

  • Setup

    Forming the C corporation, adopting the plan, coordinating the rollover, and the initial stock purchase.

  • Ongoing plan administration

    Usually a monthly or annual fee. Ask exactly which filings and tests it includes.

  • Annual valuation

    The plan's stock has to be valued every year. Find out who does it and whether it is included.

  • ERISA fidelity bond

    Required for the plan. Sometimes bundled, sometimes billed separately.

  • Corporate tax return

    The C corporation files Form 1120 every year, which is usually your CPA's fee, not the provider's.

  • SBA loan packaging

    If you are pairing ROBS with an SBA loan, some providers charge a separate one-time fee for this.

Ask every provider for two numbers in writing: your total first-year cost and your total over five years. A lower monthly fee that leaves out valuations or the fidelity bond can end up costing more than a higher fee that bundles them. Compare what each fee includes, not just the headline price.

What does "audit protection" really cover?

Audit protection is a contract between you and the ROBS provider, with its own terms and exclusions. It is not an IRS program and it does not mean the IRS will find nothing.

Providers use similar names for very different promises: audit protection, audit shield, audit assistance. Some say they cover attorney defense fees. Some only help you gather documents for the examiner. Some do not publish their terms at all. The label tells you little until you read the contract.

Ask for the actual contract language. Find out whether it pays attorneys, penalties, or both, whether there is a dollar cap, and what conduct voids it. Then ask who pays if the exam turns on something the provider designed, such as plan coverage or a valuation.

How do franchise buyers pair ROBS with an SBA loan?

Many buyers use ROBS funds as the equity injection and finance the remainder with an SBA loan, which means two parties have to work in sequence. The ROBS provider builds the plan and completes the stock purchase, and the lender needs to see those funds in the corporation's account.

Ask each provider who coordinates with the lender and whether SBA help is a separate charge. Some bundle it, some bill a one-time packaging fee, and some simply refer you to lenders they know. See our comparison of SBA vs. ROBS franchise funding and our SBA loan services for how the two fit together.

On timing, providers advertise roughly 2 to 4 weeks to set up the plan. Custodian delays are the usual reason it runs longer, so build that buffer in before your franchise agreement deadlines.

How to choose a ROBS provider: a 12-question checklist

Vetting ROBS providers comes down to asking the same twelve questions of each one and comparing the written answers. The questions map directly to what the IRS found, so a vague answer is itself information.

Franchise owner meeting with an advisor to review a checklist for vetting ROBS providers
  1. 1

    Can I get an itemized, written first-year cost?

    Setup, monthly administration, valuation, custodian, ERISA bond, and tax preparation should each appear as a line item.

  2. 2

    Who files Form 5500 every year?

    The answer should be a named party with a deadline, and the provider should never say the one-participant 5500-EZ exception applies.

  3. 3

    How are valuations done, and by whom?

    Ask whether a credentialed independent appraiser prepares the valuation and how detailed the report is. A thin one-page appraisal is one of the IRS's named concerns.

  4. 4

    Will the plan be offered to future employees?

    Plans amended so later hires cannot buy stock raise coverage and discrimination problems. Ask how the provider designs for this.

  5. 5

    How are the provider's fees paid?

    Fees paid from plan assets draw scrutiny. Ask whether you pay personally or the corporation pays, and get that in writing.

  6. 6

    What exactly does audit protection cover, and what does it exclude?

    Request the contract language, including caps, exclusions, and whether it pays attorneys, penalties, or neither.

  7. 7

    What is the provider's audit history?

    Ask how many of its plans have been examined and how those examinations ended.

  8. 8

    Is administration in-house or outsourced?

    Outsourced work is not automatically worse, but you should know who actually touches your plan.

  9. 9

    Is the plan a prototype or individually designed?

    Understand what you are adopting and who maintains plan amendments.

  10. 10

    What does it cost to unwind or exit?

    Ask about termination fees, final filings, and what happens when you sell the franchise.

  11. 11

    Can my own attorney or CPA review the documents?

    A provider confident in its work will welcome an independent review before you sign.

  12. 12

    Does the provider pay referral fees, and to whom?

    Some referrers are paid by the providers they recommend. Ask anyone recommending a provider, including us, whether they are paid.

Annual filings are the easiest place to check a claim. The Department of Labor publishes Form 5500 filing information, so you can confirm what is required before a provider describes it to you.

When is ROBS the wrong move, whichever provider you pick?

ROBS is the wrong move when the retirement money is your only safety net, the concept is unproven, or you do not want to run a compliant plan every year. Choosing a careful ROBS provider lowers the compliance risk but does nothing about the business risk.

  • Rolling most of your retirement savings into one franchise leaves little fallback if it struggles.
  • A brand with weak unit economics is a poor reason to put retirement funds at risk.
  • Annual filings, valuations, and plan access for employees never end, so an owner who dislikes paperwork should weigh that.

If that describes you, an SBA loan or another funding path may fit better. Our Am I Fundable? quiz is a quick way to see which routes your profile supports.

How does Fund My Franchise fit in?

Al helps buyers decide whether ROBS fits at all, how it pairs with an SBA loan, and how to time the two. For plan setup and administration, Fund My Franchise works with Tenet Financial Group.

Hold us to the same standard as anyone else: ask the twelve questions above, get the answers in writing, and compare at least two itemized quotes before you sign.

FAQ: ROBS providers

How much does it cost to set up a ROBS?

Setup commonly runs about $3,500 to $5,500, plus roughly $100 to $200 a month for ongoing plan administration. Those are starting prices. Valuations, an ERISA fidelity bond, corporate tax preparation, and SBA loan packaging may be billed separately, so ask for an itemized written quote covering the first year.

Who are the best ROBS providers?

No single ROBS provider is best for every buyer, and any list that ranks its own publisher first is marketing. Compare what the fees actually cover, the exact terms of any audit protection, and how each provider answers the vetting questions in this guide. The right choice is the one that gives you an itemized quote and clear answers in writing.

Is ROBS legal, and is it IRS approved?

ROBS is a recognized structure, and the IRS says it does not consider ROBS an abusive tax avoidance transaction. It also calls the arrangements questionable and has run a compliance project on them since 2009. A favorable determination letter on the plan is not IRS approval of how the plan is operated, and no ROBS provider can promise the IRS has approved its product.

What happens if the IRS audits my ROBS plan?

The IRS can examine whether the plan met coverage rules, filed Form 5500 and Form 1120, valued the stock properly, and avoided prohibited transactions. The prohibited-transaction excise tax is 15% of the amount involved, rising to 100% if it is not corrected. A provider's audit protection is a contract, not an IRS guarantee, so read what it covers and what it excludes.

Can I combine ROBS with an SBA loan for a franchise?

Yes. Many buyers use ROBS funds as the equity injection and finance the rest with an SBA loan. The two moving parts have to be coordinated, because the lender needs to see the stock purchase and the injected funds, and the ROBS plan setup takes roughly 2 to 4 weeks by providers' own estimates. Plan the order of events before you sign a franchise agreement.

Al Lesko, founder of Fund My Franchise

Al Lesko

Al Lesko has been in the franchise industry since 2009. As a certified franchise broker and the founder of Fund My Franchise, he works with prospective franchise owners on SBA loans, 401(k) rollovers, unsecured credit lines, and personal loans. See his full background at About Al.

Not sure ROBS is right for you
before you pick a provider?

Settle whether ROBS belongs in your funding plan first, then compare providers with the checklist above. An assessment with Al reviews your retirement accounts, credit, and the realistic funding paths.

Soft credit pull only
No obligation